Skip to content

Something urgent? Call us now! (852) 3416 1711

Falling concrete, rising risk of liability

By Alex Liu

Hong Kong, 30 August, 2023: Owners of old buildings who fail to carry out compulsory maintenance work have been put on notice that they face tougher action from the authorities. Numerous recent incidents of falling concrete or rendering from external walls have brought renewed focus on the issue, with the government conceding its inspection regime thus far has been too slow and lenient.

According to official figures, at the end of 2021 our city had more than 27,000 buildings that were over 30 years old. Some were built 40, 50 or even – in the case of around 3,500 blocks – more than 60 years ago. The figures include all types of property: residential, commercial, industrial and composite. Those considered most at risk of falling into disrepair are “three-nil” buildings that do not have an owners’ corporation, residents’ organisation or property management company.

Under the government’s Mandatory Building Inspection Scheme (MBIS), owners of buildings aged 30 years or above – except domestic buildings not exceeding three storeys – can be served with a statutory notice which requires them to appoint a registered inspector to examine the property and follow up with any necessary repair works. The inspector should be appointed within three months, the review completed within six months and the repairs done within a year.

Yet the scheme’s ineffectiveness was exemplified by a well-publicised incident in Mong Kok last month when fist-sized chunks of concrete rained down from a 17-storey building, the second such occurrence at the block in four days. It emerged the property was issued with an inspection notice in 2014, but its owners waited until 2018 to submit a maintenance subsidy application to the Urban Renewal Authority (URA) – the statutory body tasked with addressing inner-city decay – which only granted the request in 2021. The inspection report was handed in this past March. In summary, nine years after the inspection notice, the required repairs had still not been completed.

The government’s MBIS figures make for alarming reading. Some 4,800 buildings have outstanding inspection notices, 2,700 of which have passed the deadline for compliance. Around 900 of these have not even had an inspector appointed. Perhaps prompted by the heightened media coverage, the Buildings Department had, as of last week, sent some 700 warning letters to owners or owners’ corporations ordering them to hire an inspector immediately and provide a progress report within a month.

Secretary for Development Bernadette Linn has signalled the government will step up enforcement, telling a media briefing: “Of course, if some owners are obstinate or haven’t made an effort after repeated reminders, the department will not wait until the end of this year to prosecute them.” The authorities have since identified 30 buildings considered to be “potentially higher risk” and therefore in need of urgent inspection. This is being done by government-appointed inspectors and, should repairs be necessary, owners will need to pay a 20% surcharge.

Amid these developments, it is worth mentioning the Operation Building Bright (OBB) 2.0 programme. This is a government-funded HK$6 billion scheme, implemented by the URA, to subsidise eligible owners in co-ordinating inspection and repair works. Buildings that are able to co-ordinate the necessary works among themselves are Category 1, while those requiring government intervention – with the cost of repairs to be recovered from the owners later – are Category 2. Some 1,100 higher-risk buildings have been selected for Category 2, although the waiting time for inspection can be up to five years.

It should be stressed, of course, that such government interventions do not relieve building owners of their responsibility to ensure their properties are well maintained and in safe condition, which includes the need for regular inspections and timely repairs.

Under the Buildings Ordinance (Cap 123), anyone who fails to comply with a mandatory inspection order faces a maximum fine of HK$50,000 and one-year imprisonment. Offenders must also pay HK$5,000 each day until the order is carried out. Aside from these penalties, there is the obvious risk of criminal or civil liability for any resulting damage to persons or property.

Thus, the requirement for owners to properly maintain buildings is clear. If in doubt, citizens are strongly advised to seek professional advice. Here at BC&C we have considerable experience in property ownership and building management issues and are ready to help.

Alex Liu is Managing Partner of BC&C. He was Chairman of the Appeal Tribunal Panel (Buildings Ordinance) for nine years until 2018 and a frequent legal advisor on the TVB documentary series A Property a Day. His key areas of practice include commercial and corporate litigation, investigations by governmental bodies, and insolvency and debt restructuring. He can be contacted at alex@boasecohencollins.com.

39+ years of legal experience is just a click away.

Friendly and approachable, we are ready to answer your questions and offer you sound advice.

Contact us now

BC&C-contact-us

News & Knowledge

Learn more about what we do and what we say. Subscribe to our newsletter to ensure you receive our updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The tipples that take their toll

Hong Kong, 16 October 2024: “Getting your head down, sweetie? Jolly good idea!” So says Leonard Rossiter after causing Joan Collins to spill a drink on herself aboard a flight. It was one of a series of classic TV ads starring the pair promoting Cinzano vermouth, with Rossiter’s social-climbing buffoonery always ensuring the icily elegant […]

Read more

Law & More: Episode 45 – Anoop Gidwani

Hong Kong, 14 October 2024: In the latest episode, we welcome forensic accountant and tenacious investigator of white collar crime Anoop Gidwani, who has recently left the Independent Commission Against Corruption after 37 years of distinguished service. As well, Anoop’s unwavering commitment to integrity extends to cricket, a sport he continues to serve with distinction […]

Read more

Updating copyright for the AI landscape

By Susan Cheung and Nicole Chin Hong Kong, 7 October 2024: The Commerce and Economic Development Bureau and the Intellectual Property Department have jointly published a consultation paper, taking a significant step towards modernising Hong Kong’s copyright regime in response to the rapid advancements in artificial intelligence (AI). The paper addresses key issues regarding copyright […]

Read more

Ian McWalters delivers compelling talk

Hong Kong, 2 October 2024: A large audience gathered at the University of Hong Kong to hear former Justice of Appeal Ian McWalters deliver the sixth annual HKU-Boase Cohen & Collins Criminal Law Lecture. His talk, “The Exercise of Discretion in the Criminal Justice System”, examined discretionary decision making by law enforcement, prosecutors and judicial […]

Read more

The blurred lines of ‘medical beauty’

By Teresa Leung Hong Kong, 25 September 2024: Our city’s largely unregulated “medical beauty” industry is back in the news following the jailing of a beautician over a botched botox injection. It is the latest in a string of cases featuring unlicensed medical practices – some of them leading to permanent physical damage or even […]

Read more